How Values and Performance Intersect

Stoke Consulting | Project and Change Management

Challenge

  • We’ve all worked in teams that are dysfunctional. Their attributes are nearly always the same. There’s at least one difficult character, meetings take forever to get any resolution and progress on critical matters are either slow or stalled. In fact, progress across the whole organization is usually impacted.

  • In work we led with a major national construction firm, business growth had stalled, the executive leadership team had become disillusioned and each part of the business was unable to execute efficiently on its plan.

  • It was evident to all that the CFO was this roadblock. Meetings were unproductive with individuals exhibiting appropriate levels of frustration.

  • The MD’s authority and voice had become diminished, as he had failed to address the elephant in the room.

  • High performing individuals in the Leadership team felt exasperated, disillusioned and felt unsupported by the MD.

  • The MD and founder who had the patience of a saint, had ignored all the warning signs. Some of these included watching an individual make no contribution to team discussions, late arrival at team conferences, failing to submit financial reports either on time or at all and was unable to or unwilling to prepare cash flow forecasts. So, the worst of both worlds, a poor team player and very poor on job performance.

  • To make matters worse, the higher performing executive team members were losing faith in the MD as their own performance was being compromised, further impacting the business overall.

Solution

  • Our first step was to identify the tools and framework we could use to help the MD see what the problem is and how to deal with it. It was not just a simple case of telling the MD what the answer or solution was.

  • We decided to use the ‘A Player’ framework (adapted by Verne Harnish). This process allowed us to methodically and without too much emotion, assess each individual in the Leadership Team against two important dimensions. The first, their fit to the core values and culture of the company. And second, their actual job performance rating.

  • This is a very simplified description and the whole exercise was facilitated across 2 half-day workshops with the MD.

Outcomes

  • The facilitated workshop allowed the MD to visually see the A, B, (C and D) players. In this team, there were no C or D players.

  • This exercise was a light bulb moment, as the MD realised where the CFO plotted versus the rest of the team. He had been tolerating a person who had been holding the team and the business back, compromising his own effectiveness as leader.

  • Importantly, it was the MD who came to this conclusion, we merely facilitated the process.

  • The MD responded with enthusiasm and decisiveness to the process outcomes resulting in the almost immediate removal of the individual. It’s important to note we’re not advocating dismissal in every instance, there are many shades of grey!

  • The impact of his decision, however, was immediate. The other Leadership team members responded with a mixture of relief and renewed commitment.

  • The MD’s standing was enhanced immeasurably.

  • The business appointed a new CFO and cash forecasts; financial statements and financial processes were back in control within eight weeks.

  • This enabled the business to negotiate increased working capital with different lenders, allowing them to bid for more high value work, resulting in all business units winning more right gross margin work.

  • The entire business capability lifted.

  • The decision to appoint a new CFO also gave the MD the confidence to restructure his leadership team to facilitate and support the growth targets, which were previously thought to be out of reach.

  • The unique strength of the ‘A Players’ model lies in recognising both personal productivity, coupled with the ability of an individual to enhance the performance of those around them.

  • Research studies support the significance of these high performers. One, by McKinsey, revealed that ‘A Players’ can be up to 400% more productive than others.

  • All businesses should aim to have >90% A Players. The test, ‘would I enthusiastically re-hire this person?’

Return on Investment

The scale of growth that resulted was extraordinary, with turnover rising over 46% in under 12 months, following the appointment of a new CFO.

To learn more about the A Player framework a facilitated discussion is easy to organise and a valuable management tool.

 

Contact Us today.

Placeholder for the post heading…

Please enter your details below to access the pre-recorded webinar. Once you’ve submitted the form, you’ll be redirected to the webinar page.

* indicates required fields